Mar 23, 2015 here, walter watson offers a new interpretation of the lost second book of aristotles poetics. For some time now scholars have argued that a tenth century manuscript known as tractatus coislinianus summarizes this lost book, but up to now they have failed. In book i he argues vigorously for a political theory based on nature. In this, the fullest, sustained interpretation of aristotles poetics available in english, stephen halliwell demonstrates that the poetics, despite its laconic brevity, is a coherent statement of a challenging theory of poetic art, and it hints towards a theory of mimetic art in general. I remembered that aristotle was a rhetorphilosopher. In the absence of that book, if it ever existed, scholars have had recourse to two sources as a basis for establishing aristotle s views about the nature of comedy. Full text of on the second book of aristotles poetics. Chapter 4 of the poetics, for example, discusses the essential place of imitation in learning, and the books of the rhetoric are full of material about psychology. Poetics by aristotle, free pdf, ebook, epub global grey. The principal texts in new translations for rhetorical discussion and second comparative translation aristotle for everybody for philosophyw.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Of all the writings on theory and aestheticsancient, medieval, or modernthe most important is indisputably aristotles poetics, the first philosophical treatise to propound a theory of literature. Sir anthony kenny is a distinguished philosopher whose books include the aristotelian ethics 1978, aristotles theory of the will 1979, and aristotle on the perfect life 1992. But before he begins tackling these topics, aristotle first. The lost second book of aristotles poetics classics for all. What is poetry, how many kinds of it are there, and what are their specific effects. For oxford worlds classics he has translated aristotles eudemian ethics. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. On the second book of aristotles poetics and the source of. Because this book, as we shall see, is supposed to have contained a theory of comedy, its loss, measured by the value of the aristotelian theory of tragedy, is incalculable. A founding text of european aesthetics and literary criticism, it has shaped much of our modern understanding of the creation and impact of imaginative writing, including poetry, drama, and fiction. Aristotle defines poetry very broadly, including epic poetry, tragedy. Critical essay aristotle on tragedy in the poetics, aristotle s famous study of greek dramatic art, aristotle 384322 b. Based on richard jankos philological reconstruction of the epitome, a summary first recovered in 1839 and hotly contested thereafter, watson mounts a compelling philosophical argument that places the statements of this summary of the.
A document known as the tractatus coislinianus, first recovered in the biblioteque nationale in paris in 1839, appears to be a summary of aristotles second book. The lost second book of aristotle s poetics is a core plot element in umberto ecos bestseller novel, the name of the rose. His most recent book is a new history of western philosophy 2010. Based on richard jankos philological reconstruction of. A book called aristotles poetics for screenwriters, published after this article was written, commits the same sins as the other texts mentioned here. Such scholars fail to appreciate the achievements of robertellus, bernays, and lane cooper, who have shown us how much can be done with the extant text of the poetics in terms of uncovering a solid basis for a theory of comedy.
He determines that tragedy, like all poetry, is a kind of imitation mimesis, but adds that it has a serious purpose and uses direct action rather than narrative to achieve its ends. Its discoverer suggested that it derived from the lost second book of aristotle s poetics, which inaugurated the systematic study of comedy, but it was soon condemned as an ignorant compilation verging on forgery, and thus matters stood until the first publication of aristotle on comedy in 1984. Based on richard jankos philological reconstruction of the epitome, a summary first recovered in 1839 and hotly contested thereafter, watson mounts a compelling philosophical argument that places the statements of this summary of the aristotelian text in their true context. The lost second book of aristotles poetics is a core plot element in umberto eco s bestseller novel, the name of the rose. An intellectual adventure of the most stimulating kind. Aristotle s poetics hardcover august 8, 2015 by aristotle author 4. The plot is the source and the soul of tragedyin his nearcontemporary. Aristotles intellectual range was vast, covering most of the sciences and many of the arts, including biology, botany, chemistry, ethics, history, logic, metaphysics, rhetoric, philosophy of mind, philosophy of science, physics, poetics, political theory, psychology, and zoology. Aristotle writes also that he will address catharsis and an analysis of what is funny. Aristotle himself respected homer so much that he personally corrected a copy of the iliad for his student alexander, who carried it all over the world. Aristotle does this by attempting to explai n poetry through first principles, and by classifying poetry into it s different genres and component parts. Despite its vague beginning, the poetics has been a central document in the study of aesthetics and literature for centuries, proving especially influential during the renaissance. In point of fact, euripides, the last of the three great tragic poets of ancient greece, wrote many plays that violated the logical and structured principles of aristotle s poetics in a conscious effort to depict a world that he saw as neither logical nor structured.
It is simply a more elongated example of bending, twisting and misrepresenting aristotles words to support a. A penetrating, nearcontemporary account of greek tragedy, it demonstrates how the elements of plot, character and spectacle combine to produce pity and fear and why we derive pleasure from this apparently painful process. Jan 01, 2012 in the poetics, aristotle writes that he will speak of comedybut there is no further mention of comedy. Aristotle s poetics is the earliestsurviving work of dramatic theory and the first extant philosophical treatise to focus on literary theory. Read download the lost second book of aristotles poetics pdf. The lost second book of aristotle s poetics is a core plot element in umberto eco s bestseller novel, the name of the rose. The tractatus, thought to have been written in the. The centerpiece of aristotles work is his examination of tragedy. On the second book of aristotle s poetics and the source of theophrastus definition of tragedy is an article from harvard studies in classical philology, volume 28 view more articles from harvard studies in classical philology. Aristotle s poetics seeks to address the different kinds of poetry, the structure of a good poem, and the division of a poem into its component parts. Aristotle s poetics is the most influential book on poetry ever written. Here, at last, aristotle s lost second book is found again. Based on richard janko s philological reconstruction of the epitome, a summary first recovered in 1839 and hotly contested thereafter, watson mounts a compelling philosophical argument that places the statements excerpted from the aristotelian text. Jun 29, 2012 the lost second book of aristotles poetics ebook written by walter watson.
As the shortest book ive got on my literature student bookshelf, this dover thrift edition poetics is the cheapest, and most flimsy, but completely worthwhile book. Full text of on the second book of aristotles poetics and. Aristotle supposedly wrote a second book on comedy, which is now lost. It is especially popular with screenwriters as seen in many script gurus howto books. Walter watson of all the writings on theory and aesthetics, ancient, medieval, or modern, the most important is indisputably aristotle s poetics, the first philosophical treatise to propound a theory of. The tradition of a lost second book of the poetics 1 since the renaissance any treatment of aristotle s poetics has discussed and lamented the loss of a second book. Aristotles poetics, halliwell university of chicago press. The lost second book of aristotles poetics by walter. The lost second book of aristotles poetics 9780226274119. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of poetics and what it means. These legislations on literature went on to have a significant influence throughout the ages and, in fact, remained prevalent and often unquestioned until the 19th century. Mar 04, 20 the natural appendix to the politics is the poetics ably translated by seth benardete and michael davis as aristotle on poetics under st. Aristotle s poetics is one of the most powerful, perceptive and influential works of criticism in western literary history. Though the precise origins of aristotle s poetics are not known, researchers believe that the work was composed around 330 bce and was preserved primarily through aristotle s students notes.
Buy the lost second book of aristotle s poetics by watson, walter isbn. Core terms edit mimesis or imitation, representation, or expression, given that, e. The new york times this book contains the celebrated butcher translation of aristotle s poetics, faced, page by page, with the complete greek text as reconstructed by mr. Walter watson, the lost second book of aristotles poetics.
Based on richard jankos philological reconstruction of the epitome, a summary first recovered in 1839 and hotly contested thereafter, watson mounts a compelling philosophical argument that places the statements excerpted from the aristotelian text in their true context. The lost second book of aristotle s poetics by walter watson. He defines poetry as a medium of imitation that seeks to represent or duplicate life through character, emotion, or action. Aristotle s approach to the phenomenon of poetry is quite different from plato s. Of all the writings on theory and aestheticsancient, medieval, or modernthe most important is indisputably aristotle s poetics, the first philosophical treatise to propound a theory of literature. Read download the lost second book of aristotles poetics. The lost second book of aristotles poetics bryn mawr classical. Aug 08, 2015 aristotles poetics hardcover august 8, 2015 by aristotle author 4. The lost second book of aristotles poetics classics. Here, walter watson offers a new interpretation of the lost second book of aristotles poetics. In the poetics, aristotle s famous study of greek dramatic art, aristotle 384322 b. The deficiency is explained on that basis by gercke,4 following rose.
The lost second book of aristotles poetics walter watson. Aristotles poetics chapters 15 summary and analysis. Pdf the second book of aristotles politics francisco. The author offers a fresh interpretation of the lost second book of aristotles poetics. The lost second book of aristotles poetics by walter watson. The lost second book of aristotles poetics bryn mawr. Assessing this theory against the background of earlier greek views on poetry and art, particularly. Its discoverer suggested that it derived from the lost second book of aristotles poetics, which inaugurated the systematic study of comedy, but it was soon condemned as an ignorant compilation verging on forgery, and thus matters stood until the first publication of aristotle on comedy in 1984. He was the founder of formal logic, devising for it a finished. The existence of a second book is proved by ancient. As of 20, all three are highly recommendable as the best scholarly translations of these three works. In the poetics, aristotle writes that he will speak of comedybut there is no further mention of comedy. Aristotle second book of poetics the book the lost second book of aristotle s. Poetics aristotle aristotles poetics aims to give an account of poetry.
Strangely, though, the poetics itself is rarely read with the kind of sensitivity its critics claim to possess, and the thing criticized is not the book aristotle wrote but a caricature of it. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of aristotle 384322 b. The poetics is in part aristotle s response to his teacher, plato, who argues in the republic that poetry is representation of mere appearances and is thus misleading and morally suspect. Of all the writings on theory and aesthetics ancient, medieval, or modern the most important is indisputably aristotles poetics, the first philosophical treatise to propound a theory of literature. Theres no introduction to the book, just a note about when it was written circa 330bc and about aristotle himself, taking up less than a page. Aristotles poetics the science of tragedy classical. Meanwhile, while teaching at st andrews, i came across a mysterious and forgotten text that, when it was first published in 1839, was identified as an abstract of the lost second book of aristotle s poetics, his missing treatise on comedy. The editors 300page exposition and interpretation follows.
Based on richard jankos philological reconstruction of the epitome, a summary first recovered in 1839 and hotly contested thereafter, watson mounts a compelling philosophical argument that places the statements of this summary of the aristotelian. Here, walter watson offers a new interpretation of the lost second book of aristotle s poetics. The book the lost second book of aristotles the lost second book of aristotles poetics, watson the chicago distribution center has reopened and is fulfilling orders. With a critical text and a translation of the poetics. Aristotle s politics is a key document in western political thought. The second book of the politics has been object of multiple considerations, but it has called the attention of the scholars mainly because of its detailed criticism of platos political projects, especially the republic. In poetics, aristotle outlines what he sees as the essential components of tragedy, along with a few interesting literary devices that can be thrown in to spice things up. It discusses things like unity of plot, reversal of situation, and character in the context of greek tragedy, comedy and epic poetry. Aristotle in his books on the aristotelian philosophy. As mentioned above, there has long been speculation about the existence of a lost second book of the poetics dealing with aristotle s theory of comedy. The book aims, among other things, to answer platos criticisms of representative art. The titles might suggest that these works are primarily relevant to themes of literature, but they in fact fit more tightly with the themes of human life explored in aristotle ethics. Its discoverer suggested that it derived from the lost second book of aristotles poetics, which inaugurated the systematic study of comedy, but it was soon condemned as an ignorant compilation verging on forgery, and thus matters stood until the.
The lost second book of aristotles poetics walmart. Aristotle writes also that he will address catharsis and an analysis of of all the writings on theory and aestheticsancient, medieval, or modernthe most important is indisputably aristotles poetics, the first philosophical treatise. The lost second book of aristotles poetics ebook, 2012. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read the lost second book of aristotles poetics. The book builds on richard jankos aristotle on comedy 1984, which argued that the supposed abstract or epitome of poetics book two, in the manuscript known as tractatus coislinianus, is actually based on the lost second book, an opinion much debated over the previous century. For some time now scholars have argued that a tenth century manuscript known as tractatus coislinianus summarizes. The lost second book of aristotles poetics in searchworks. Here, at last, aristotles lost second book is found again. This paper provides an overview and commentary of aristotle s theory of poetry, of drama, and of narrative structure, as presented the poetics.
11 192 618 255 476 672 1417 970 853 236 810 1242 231 719 864 907 546 1147 152 832 1373 464 1443 550 1332 798 253 826 1016 740 1052 551 1370 715 754 680 1178 842 465